| 1957: Don Gilbert | | 1990: James Taylor |
| 1961: Wayne Martin | | 1991: Randy Kehr |
| 1966: James Burt | | 1992: Richard Zahodnic |
| 1967: James Burt | | 1993: Anna Ibrahim |
| 1968: James Burt | | 1994: Bruce Brenn |
| 1969: Jim Hindelang | | 1995: Tom Kane |
| 1970: Oscar Sasson | | 1996: Carl Haas |
| 1971: Gerald Sims | | 1997: Jim Wlosinski |
| 1975: Gerald Sims | | 1998: Homer Engert |
| 1973: Frank Alvarez | | 1999: Anne Hamilton |
| 1974: Jim Bogan | | 2000: David Panzlau |
| 1975: Raymond Ingham | | 2001: Beth Spence |
| 1976: Jeri (Reynolds) Eiserman | | 2002: Kathy Gurin |
| 1977: Jeri (Reynolds) Eiserman | | 2003: Tom Kane |
| 1978: Thomas Glass | | 2004: Chris Kitchen |
| 1979: Karen Shaffran-Larson | | 2005: Carl Haas |
| 1980: Karen Shaffran-Larson | | 2006: Paul Loik |
| 1981: Raymond Ingham | | 2007: Emily Zyla |
| 1982: Thomas Glass | | 2008: Al Moss |
| 1983: Thomas Glass | | 2009: Paul Loik |
| 1984: Raymond Ingham | | |
| 1985: John Darin | | |
| 1986: Homer Engert | | |
| 1987: John Darin | | |
| 1988: Larry Bryant | | |
| 1989: Marge Perech | | |
| | | |